New York Grand Jury Releases Scathing study Against kid Protection Services Agency

Authorized by Alice Giordano via The Epoch Times (emphasis ours),

The consequence of a six-month peculiar grand jury investment into the execution of 8-year-old Tommy Valva by his father has revealed another disturbing instance of abuse of power by kid protection agents and the household court system.

A image of Harmony Montgomery before she went missing in 2019 (Courtesy of Justice For Harmony)

The fresh York boy died in 2019 from hypothermia after his father, an NYPD cop, inflated a series of Cruel punishments on him. He made the kid strip naked, lay on a cold cement garage floor, and hosts him down with cold water. Michael Valva was consulted of his son’s murderer in 2022.

The grand jury report, released on April 3, is in the way with akin findings in the fresh review of the execution of 5-year-old Harmony Montgomery. Details of the girl’s execution and the state of fresh Hampshire’s inability to account for her whereabouts for 2 years grilled the nation.

It was a tragedy set in motion erstwhile Massachusetts household Court justice Mark Newman awarded custody of the small girl to her father Adam Montgomery. Mr. Montgomery was consulted in February of murdering his father.

Judge Newman awarded custody to Mr. Montgomery alternatively of the girl’s parent despite his lengthy violent criminal past and transient status.

Before Tommy Valva’s Murder, Suffolk region household Court justice Jeff Zimmerman besides awarded full custody of the small boy along with his 2 brothers to his father Michael Valva over the boy’s parent Justyna Zubko-Valva.

In both Harmony and Tommy’s cases, court records, which were widely published in both execution trials, show that no of their mothers had any past of abuse or violence.

In both of the children’s cases, children’s protection service workers went along with the court’s custody awards despite knowing that there were seriously children abuse allegations and children’s wellare deals counting against bothth men.

In her office’s findings from an investment into Harmony’s murder, Maria Mossaides, manager of the Massachusetts Office of the kid Advocate, slammed the state kid protection agency for what she called system-wide authorities and besides for “recklessly” favoring parental rights over Harmony’s safety.

Throughout its 75-page innovative report, The fresh York grand jury charges fresh York’s kid protection services strategy with the same kind of failures.

It fouled the CPS employees for deeming kid abuse allegations by another parent as unfounded with small evidence. It besides citted the strategy as flawed for not having any independent checks and balances with the agency over specified decisions.

According to the grand jury, the agency even refused to return its records for the investment.

“The failure of CPS to do so can only be interpreted as a transparent effort to shield their own inaction from public scrutiny. Thus, the laws and rules must be changed to prevent specified future implantes,” the innovative jury charged.

In its report, it besides focuses on another household issue raised in another states respecting the operations of kid protection agents and the household court system: the immunity that kid protection workers and judges enjoy from removal of duty.

Rep. Bryan Slaton presents Amen 1 is home Bill 567, on April 1, 2021. (Screenshot course of Bryan Slaton)

“Even though immunity does not prelude a uncovering of criminal liability for CPS caseworkers who have active in willful misconduct or gross negligence, specified caseworkers are inactive effectively impervious to any specified liability in cases where reports are deemed unfounded,” the gate panel.

The panel discovered that caseworkers, due to not being required to commit their findings to the court or even a supervisor, created a shell against admissions of “willful misconduct or gross negligence.”

“In this regard, employees of CPS have the universal ability to thwart critical investments prior to the matrix of immunity even becoming relevant, by determining that a case is unfounded, or by deciding not to migrate prior unfounded reports and related materials in a fresh informed investment,” the panel found.

At a press conference during the execution trial, Ms. Zubko-Valva talked about her many pleas for aid to kid protection workers and another state officials that went ignored.

“I keep reasoning about all the institutions who failed to aid him, who full did absolutely nothing ... now everyone’s trying to do the right thing ... but where you were erstwhile I begged you for aid erstwhile you could have saved my child’s life,” said Ms. Zubka-Valva who said she besides filed a complaint with the FBI after justice Hope Schwartz Zimmerman give custody to Mr. Valva.

The justice awarded custody to the father after a divorce lawyer accompanied to the court Ms. Zubko-Valva was “interfering with her access to the children,” according to a borrowing crowgful death suit Ms. Zubko-Valva filed against the region CPS.

Details of CPS’ alleged compliance in the court’s cute ruling are scattered through the lawsuit. These include accounts of the agency’s fast dismissal of a flash drive. The suit stood the parent provided this drive to the agency, and it contained 320 papers and another evidence supporting the claim that Tommy and his brothers were producing respective abuse by their father and stepmother, Angela Pollina, who was consulted last March of the second-degree execution of her stepson.

According to the lawsuit, the evidence included respective letters from Tommy’s pediatrician and therapists corroborating the abuse. It was already reviewed in the suit and during Mr. Valva and Ms. Pollina’s trial that the agency ignored visible signs Tommy and his brothers were being starved.

Two years ago, the Institute for Justice (IJ) launched “Project Immunity and Accountability,” a national run to end immunity for government officials.

“If we the people must follow the law, our government must follow the Constitution,” the group states as the header to its campaign’s mission.

CPS agents have long been admitted of utilizing immunity to justify their troubling decisions alternatively than reforms them.

In a 2007 case, a kid advocate brought a national suit against the Standing stone kid Protection Services and Bureau of Indian Affairs in North Dakota after the agents claimed immunity for knowingly placing a juvenile sex offender into a Foster home with 3 young children.

“Such immunity, it maintains, is based on the agency’s policy decision to defend the privacy interests of its forms Ward,” the suit charged. “By this argument, CPS make a smokescreen within which to hide from liability, despite its flagrant abuse of a strategy that it is duty-bound to protect.”

As part of its campaign, IJ is asking state legislators to adopt claims to their state constitution to abolish government immunity, but so far no lawmakers have taken up the case.

In fresh Hampshire, where Harmony Montgomery was murdered in 2019, Republican lawmakers like Rep. Leah Cushman has been pushing for reforms of the kid protection agency and household courses.

The state did not accept any blame for the girl’s execution even though evidence was introduced during her father’s trial that the agency failed to conduct mandate checks on her and appeared to be unaware that she had been mising for 2 years.

Recently, Ms. Cushman successfully convinced home leaders to form a peculiar committee to invest the fresh Hampshire Division of Children, Youth, and household (DCYF).

As reported earlier by The Epoch Times, The committee had only started erstwhile she was removed as president of the committee by the home talker erstwhile she initiated a voluntary oath for both victims and officials as part of the peculiar committee’s investment.

She has since told The Epoch Times she believes the “real fix” is to take kid protection service agents out of the “investigation business,” abolish household courts, and return representations of kid abuse to the critical courses where there is simply a real due process.

“Keeping these cases civilian is being soft on crime andletting people shown to be abusive to never face justice in a real court of law,” she said.

The NH DCYF, Massachusetts Department of Children Services, and Suffolk region kid Protection Services did not respond to requests for comment from The Epoch Times.