
Over the last twelve years growth companies have dominated the stock market, but past shows that they were not always the best investment. Which strategy works best in the long word and what risks do it entail? We compare the results of six popular investment strategies, we check how they handled themselves during crises and what is worth paying attention to erstwhile building their own portfolio.
Between 1995 and 1999, the index of large American growth companies Russell 1000 Growth gained more than 300%, clearly more than inexpensive companies compared to their profits. An investor who looked at these results in the early 2000s had good reason to believe that it was best to buy companies that rapidly increased profits.
The next decade looked completely different. USD 100,000 invested in growth companies in early 2000 was worth $66.6 1000 at the end of 2009. The same amount invested in low-cost companies (value) grew to USD 127,7 thousand. In both cases, I included reinvested dividends.
After 2010, the roles reversed again. Growth companies, drawn by the largest technology companies, left inexpensive companies far behind. The 2012–2025 ranking again points to a clear winner. This time his largest companies have almost everyone who bought ]]>popular ETF]]> to the global stock market.
Which strategy earned the most between 2012 and 2020?
Source: own development
- Growth companies are companies that increase gross and profits rapidly.
- The strategy of a strong trend (momentum) buys shares that have grown most in fresh months.
- High quality companies have advanced profitability, unchangeable performance and tiny debt.
- Low value companies are valued at low value in relation to profits or assets.
- The low volatility strategy (minimum volatility) selects shares to reduce the volatility of the full portfolio.
- High dividend strategy (high dividend yield) selects companies with a advanced current payout, which besides pass quality filters.
The illustration below shows how much would be worth at the end of 2025 USD 100,000 invested in early 2012 in each of these strategies and in the full MSCI planet index. The results include dividends reinvested after deduction of the withholding taxation but do not include ETF costs or taxes paid by the investor. The grey post is the full MSCI planet index.
Source: own improvement based on MSCI data
Growth companies increased capital more than six times, and strategies of strong trend and advanced quality small less. The full MSCI planet index has increased the value of investments about 5 times. inexpensive companies with low volatility and advanced dividends gave about threefold growth. All indexes reinvested dividends, so a weaker consequence ]]>dividend strategy]]> You don't get paid out.
Two of the top 3 strategies have a very akin lead. At the end of September 2026, six of the 10 largest positions of MSCI planet Growth were besides in the top 10 of MSCI planet Quality. Among them were NVIDIA, Apple and Broadcom, but besides Eli Lilly and ASML. specified companies rapidly increase profits and have very advanced profitability, so they meet the criteria of both strategies at once.
14 years is simply a short passage of the past of the stock exchange, in which 1 group of companies had an exceptionally good streak. To see if the advantage of growth companies is the rule, you gotta look further back.
Growth or value? Almost 50 Years of History
For comparison in the long word we usage Russell 1000 Growth and Russell 1000 Value indices. These include large US companies and have been a key mention point for investment styles in this marketplace for decades. Indexes were created in 1987, so earlier data was played backwards.
The illustration shows how much both indexes averaged in 4 full decades from 1980 to 2019, with reinvested dividends.
Source: Data-based own improvement Frank Russell Company (L. Chan, J. Lakonishok) and Invesco/Lipper
No kind always won permanently. In the 1980s, companies were better off cheap, in the 1990s growth. In the first decade of the 21st century, growth companies lost on average about 4% per year and made inexpensive money. After 2010, the advantage returned to growth again.
Continue reading: ]]>Which strategy for investing in shares earns the most? We compare results and risks]]>
]]>Fund that was not to lose – and lost everything]]>
Author: ]]>Piotr Chuszno]]>

















