Was Chomsky wrong?

niepoprawni.pl 2 weeks ago

This is what I found on X: ‘Chomsky was wrong. fresh investigation from Cornell shows that the brain does not build hierarchical grammatical trees (as Chomsky claimed since 1957). Instead, we usage linear sequences — foretell the next words based on the context of the erstwhile ones, just like the LLM models. Language is simply a stream of prediction, not rigid mathematical rules.”

This is an crucial discovery! However, “Chomsky was wrong, the brain acts like ChatGPT” It's besides far-fetched. The survey shows that the human head besides represents linear language patterns that do not include conventional hierarchical components. However, it does not show that we can do without the recursive mechanics of building structures — and this is simply a central component of Chomsky’s position.

The existence of an additional method of processing the language does not prove the absence of this Chomsky recursion. There's an analogy to LLM's usage of series patterns, but it's not evidence that the brain works the same way. The survey extends the image of human language skills. It shows that man besides thinks like LLMy, so he predicts linearly the next words, but does not show that he only thinks so.

Grzegorz GPS Swiderski
]]>Twitter.com/gps65]]>
]]>t.me/CanalBlogeraGPS]]>

Read Entire Article