Szymon Holownia, talker of the Sejm, met with president Andrzej Duda to present the assumptions of the alleged "accidental Act". The task concerns, among another things, the determination of the validity of the presidential elections by the ultimate Court in the composition of judges and neo-judges, who, for the purposes of dinner, Tuska will abruptly be decently cast, and the “judgment” issued with them will not be a insignificant legal defect. After the meeting, the Holovnia stressed that changes were essential to avoid possible legal and systemic chaos.
"Thank you, Mr President, for gathering me in a meaningful way. I convinced the president that we were on the verge of possible legal and systemic chaos in an external state threat. all effort to correct this situation is worth doing," wrote the talker of the Sejm on X.
The Chancellery of the Sejm assessed the gathering as constructive. "The gathering of the talker of the Sejm with the president was constructive and ran in a meaningful atmosphere," the press office said. In commenting on the discussions, the Hołównia pointed out that the exchange of comments was substantive and necessary.
Assumptions of the Act
The task assumes that the validity of the election of the president of the Republic of Poland would be decided by the full ultimate Court (which includes judges and neojudges without the power to issue judgments), alternatively than, as is presently the case, the illegal Chamber of Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs in the settlement of neojudges. The Hołównia argued that this change was intended to strengthen legitimacy in the eyes of citizens.
READ ALSO: The “Rejudices” issued by the neo-Judges will be covered by a legal flaw clause. TK in the current composition is not a court
The paper was previously presented to parliamentary clubs and parliamentary circles. The Marshal announced that he would strive for the task to gain broad political support.
Thank you, Mr President, for gathering me in a meaningful way. I convinced the president that we were on the verge of possible legal and systemic chaos in an external state threat. Any effort to correct this situation is worth doing.
— Simon Holownia (@symon_townia) December 20, 2024
Policy responses to the project
The Holownia task gained preliminary support from the ruling coalition, which could announce the chances of it being pushed through. The Confederate, although initially critical of the current regime, declared willing to consider the proposal.
"We request a constitutional reset, but we do not exclude support for solutions that can improve the state's operation," said Bartłomiej Pejo of the Confederation.
The law and justice expressed their firm opposition. Members of this organization considered the task incompatible with the Constitution of Poland.
"The validity and nullity of the presidential elections is decided by the Chamber of Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs of the ultimate Court, consisting of judges appointed by the president of Poland, elected by 10.5 million Poles. This protest is simply a constitutional attack on the Polish state" emphasised Przemysław Czarnek.
According to Czarnek, the problems identified by the Holovnia should be addressed at the level of the State Election Commission, not through changes in the powers of the ultimate Court.
Does the "accidental Act" have a chance to implement?
The controversy around the task indicates major legislative challenges. The hoarding home argues that changes are essential to prevent chaos at key moments for the state as presidential elections. On the another hand, allegations of possible non-compliance with the Polish Constitution and accusations of an assassination of the current legal order may effectively inhibit the work on the project.
Summary
The proposal for an emergency bill shows the hypocrisy of the regulation of law that Bodnar spoke of and the emotionally unstable marshal himself. At present, the Holovnia for the purposes of recognising neojudges as judges who, although not having an active mandate to issue judgments in this case, will have it. We remind you that erstwhile the cases pardoned by Duda of criminals (Kaminski and Wąsik) were recognized by neo-Judges of Holovnia from the Sejm pulpit, he gave speeches that these persons are not judges and their position is not applicable to the dismissal of the mandate to convicted criminals.
Bodnar acted likewise erstwhile the case of Barski was examined by the neojudges of the SN. In a communication on Platform X: "SN judges defend their own positions and politicize justice. They want to block the settlement process. Today's position of 3 neojudges is not a ultimate Court resolution and is not binding. I will not get off the way of restoring independent judiciary and prosecution to citizens."
We remind you that specified a solution as proposed by the emotionally unstable Marshal Hołownia is contrary to Article 441 kpk.
The Sun's neo-judges defend their own positions and politicize the justice system. They want to block the settlement process. Today's position of 3 neojudges is not a ultimate Court resolution and is not binding.
I'm not getting off the way of bringing back independent citizens...
— Adam Bodnar (@Adbodnar) September 27, 2024
Continued here:
Hypocrisy of the Law! Hołownia met with Duda on the alleged "accidental Act"
