Since the time of the tapes, Renata Beger has appeared in the dictionary of political journalism the concept of "5D chess", most frequently ironically utilized to distance itself from suspicious explanation of events by pointing to besides many variables.
However, erstwhile Paulina Matysiak of Together announced on Thursday that she had set up the “Yes for Development” movement with Marcin Horala, a associate of the Law and erstwhile typical of the Government of the United Right of the CPK, there were actually only 2 variables – a reaction of her own party, which had been building a position in opposition to the Horala organization for years, and a reaction of its own voters, tested during months of intense media activity, focused mainly on CPK.
Perhaps Matysiak, announcing the creation of the movement, was unaware that her organization would not respond with the chorus of support. Finally, to initiate fresh movements, e.g. by electrons from Poland 2050 and the Confederation, their leaders would surely respond with joy. Of course, if it were the good of Poland.
Consider what Horal himself thought, the successor of Jack Bartosiak (who was loud again recently) in the CPK. most likely something like, “So we do it. With Paulina Matysiak – after improvement without organization colors. People together would be stupid not to respond to specified an initiative with mad enthusiasm.”
As you know, fresh Left and Together do not experience the most successful period. The erstwhile is accused of failing to push its own agenda into a coalition with the Liberals, Together – not even effort to do so. Horała, most likely on his own and without consummation with his own environment, decided to throw the lifeline to both parties, inviting MP Matysiak to a selfless, confidential cooperation on a task she truly cares about. There was an agreement that the prophets looked over ideological divisions, supported by people from different ends of the political spectrum—from the alf-left with Rafał Woś at the head of Sławomir Mentzen. Let's quit political pushbacks erstwhile it comes to a large patriotic pull.
Who harms the Left more?
That Party Together reacts by suspension and the outrage at the joint initiative of her MP with 1 of the faces of the PiS, she could not foresee Matysiak herself. She had to take into account different scenarios: revolutionary enthusiasm or relent kindness, a large joyful divided of the teammates, who could now usually legally support Tusk and Kaczor equally, could turn distant from the ability to manage the institutions over which the coalitions of October 15 now exercise power, or slow build a fresh Cepecan-altleft force on the left under the written trust board. However, it would be pure stupidity and political suicide to defraud the good intentions of the Member. Together against improvement – that's what it is!
And yet, although it may have seemed that the deficiency of organization ecstasy Together is the least likely script – it has just been realised. The shocking reaction of old comrades and companions is the best argument that no chess game could win here. Known for his insightful analyses, Michał Kolanko wrote that "the Left OF Obviousness (emphasis on me) did not gotta respond so rapidly and so harshly." The knee is constantly playing political chess 5D, facing allegations of advising politicians on the 1 hand, and regularly proving that his advice is not worth a pound of rhizomes. This time, however, we do not learn from the text that the reaction would advise the fresh Left and Together, apart from the proposition to respond slow and gently. But waiting is not the way to solve all problem.
In any case, contrary to journalists and common sense, the milk spilled: a suspended MP, the improvement of Poland under question. However, there were doubts about the moral legitimacy of the suspension itself. Here comes the second large unknown, that is the consequence of voters, for more than six months, who have been cheering for the extraordinary demonstration of political will and determination presented by Matysiak in the media from the Republic to the "Networks".
The X/Twitter leftists traditionally accused skeptics of reluctant alliances with PiS liberating and prayers raised to Tusk. They asked not without grounds: did they love the MP, fighting for the CPK, which all professed infrastructure and disgusting prose of the “worldview” dispute (without controversy – as Kolanko writes) harm the organization more than x, y or z? Didn't Biedron, Gdula, Nowack, Miller and Teodor Duracz deserve to cancel more? And why does Matysiak waste himself among these freaks anyway?
They were furious after further embarrassments and deficiency of conclusions on the essential changes in the organization authorities of the left-wing electorate and together yet sided with the popular MP, but could not be predicted.
Matysiak on the PiS list?
After this series of wonders and wonders, we'll have another uncertain weeks. Will Paulina Matysiak defy the insistent push of a treacherous party-mother into the hands of the Law and Justice, humble herself and apologize for the unfortunate initiative? Will it emergence up from the blow of erstwhile comrades who did not realize her political vision? Will she inactive be the independent and self-serving political fighter that millions have loved, and will she stay uncompromisingly faithful to the left's ideals as part of an organization that is kindly and financially supported by the second squad in the table?
Or will he become the face of a cross-party traffic for the airport and – without saving harsh words to 1 or the another politician of the Law and Justice organization – he will prove to be an independent expert? And only sometimes will he jump out of a ballot card on lists another than the usual, but providing a peaceful career for years, like another idealistic genius misunderstood in his own ranks, Luke Kohut?
Stop. We're entering very inelegant ground. Suggesting that associate Matysiak would abandon the rights of women, LGBT+ people and another minorities, and all the remainder of the cases that disagree Together and the Laws, even after months of support and presence in the media of alt-left radicals, are liberal delusions. Kohut means Silesia, Matysiak means CPK, period.
It's just that something happened to me erstwhile we here on the commentary are considering the possible effects of Matysiak's decision and we find that the fresh cooperation will not bring any naive additional votes, due to the fact that writers in life will not vote together...
Maybe not. But there's any patronizing note in it, possibly sexist. The alleged average people or even publicists who observe politics frequently seem to realize more from it than those who deal with it professionally, and politicians do not rush to get them out of error. Meanwhile, as the latest communicative teaches, in the places taken from the list of parties, which adopt impertinent politicians and politicians – suspended, spat, laziness and wounded for good hearts in their own environment – fresh transfers meet with large kindness. Monika Pawłowska, who this week jumped from the letter of the PiS into the parliamentary benches to replace Mariusz Kamiński, knows this. erstwhile SLD and Spring politician liked not only voters, but also colleagues, specified as Przemysław Czarnek. And Pawłowska did not even have her close writing heart idée fix.
Concordat?
As I recall, thanks to Bankier service, CPK's spending on CSR activities, including the budget for gifts for friendly local governments and parishes, consumed 250 million PLN during the time of PiS, another fewer twelve were spent on promotion (although, by the way, the foundation of gifts to parishes is hard to consider as anti-promotion). It would be a pity to lose specified social capital – and not only.
By putting aside speculations, scenarios and conjecture, it is impossible to hide that for Together and the fresh Left the decision of Matysiak will have only disastrous consequences. The charges of collaboration with the Law and Justice, the Law and Justice for radicalism, the deficiency of origin or bad campaigns by their own electorate will continue. For now, the Left is likely to lose 1 MP, but the process of consuming 6% is just beginning. The current atmosphere and morale after the non-transfer of Matysiak – whether in fresh Left or in Together – will not slow it down. On the wave promised by the publicists of depolarization should accidentally grow mainly PiS and PO.
It is hard to blame Paulina Matysiak for her deficiency of illusions about her own formation and the lesson of political pragmatism, which she gave (of course by full chance and against her own intentions) to her colleagues, who have been decomposing helplessly for months erstwhile they asked about sending the Black 1 to quit or expeling religion from schools, although we have a concordat. Especially I made my own demands. self-solvation of the current parliamentary left after the defeat in the Euro-election. And yet, after all, I sometimes miss Renata Beger.
