In fresh years, the character of St John Paul II was the mark of intense attacks of utmost leftist and anti-clerical environments. In many publications there were accusations that as a Kraków metropolitan he was expected to hide pedophile crimes among clergymen. Among another things, it is simply a scandalous “French 3” study by TVN. Meanwhile, the latest journalistic findings based on the analysis of the archives of Kraków curia show an image contrary to these accusations.
Compromise with the anti-cleric left. Journalists, who were the first to gain access to the reopened archives of Kraków curia, analysed papers concerning respective clergy accused of crimes against minors. Their conclusions are clear: in available materials No evidence found For a card. Karol Wojtyla in any way covered up pedophilia.
This is not the end – the papers show that erstwhile information about serious abuses appeared, concrete actions were taken by him: suspension of priests in duties, order to leave the parish or send for research. In any cases, the decisions of Wojtyla were made even earlier than the actions of the state authorities.
The analysis of the files concerning, among others, the priests Eugeni Surgent and Józef Loranc indicates that they were removed from pastoral work and subjected to further restrictions. This does not mean, of course, that all decisions taken in the 1960s or 1970s met today's standards of protection for minors. However, the papers available do not support the claim that the future Pope is aware of the concealment of crimes.
These facts are fresh to the media run of fresh years. Many publications depict John Paul II almost as a symbol of the systematic cover-up of crimes in the Church. It was frequently based on interpretations of fragmentary documents, intermediate accounts, or materials created by peerless security.
Such a message had a strong emotional speech and was part of a wider ideological dispute. For environments critical of the Church (Jews, Left) the figure of John Paul II became a symbol, whose authority had to be undermined at all costs, specified as lies and conspiracy theories. As a result, far-reaching accusations have frequently appeared in public debate before a full analysis of available archives has been carried out.
There is no uncertainty that cases of sexual abuse of minors in the Church have been a drama of many people and require a fair settlement. However, utilizing this subject to fight ideologically with the Church or with circumstantial historical figures leads to serious distortions of public debate.
The fresh papers indicate that the accusations against Karol Wojtyla are not confirmed in the sources. Therefore, journalistic integrity requires that these findings besides be made public. However, it frequently turns out that information that undermines earlier thesis does not rise as much media interest as original, sensational accusations. TVN - as you might anticipate - took water in your mouth.
A dispute around the card form. Karol Wojtyła shows how easy simplified narratives are created in the media space. It is adequate for respective loud publications to contain a certain image in the public consciousness – even if later studies of archives do not confirm it. Therefore, peculiar care is needed in specified delicate matters. past should not be decided on the basis of media emotions, but on the basis of a reliable analysis of papers and context of the era.
OUR COMMENTS: The communicative on the hiding of pedophilia in the Church by Cardinal Wojtyla is created precisely the same way as the conspiracy explanation about alleged mass killings of Indian children in Canadian residence schools, led by priests and nuns. This is no longer an accident, but alternatively a standard play by the enemies of the Church to discourage Catholics from their faith. It is not known from the point of view of the planet revolution that Catholicism is the top enemy to be destroyed by all means.
We besides recommend: Unis angry after Nawrocki vetoe in SAFE
